Regression Model Fitting With Quadratic Term Leads to Different Conclusion in Economic Analysis of Washington State Smoking Ban [Response to Letter]
2011

Response to Letter on Washington State Smoking Ban Analysis

publication

Author Information

Author(s): Boles Myde, Dent Clyde, Dilley Julia, Maher Julie E., Boysun Michael J., Reid Terry

Primary Institution: Multnomah County Health Department and Oregon Public Health Division

Conclusion

The authors maintain that their segmented regression model provides a better fit for taxable retail sales data following the smoking ban than the quadratic model proposed by Ma and McClintock.

Supporting Evidence

  • The authors argue that their segmented model has a slightly higher R² value than the quadratic model, suggesting a better fit.
  • They assert that both models indicate an increase in taxable retail sales post-smoking ban.

Takeaway

The authors disagree with another study's conclusions about the impact of a smoking ban on sales, saying their analysis is more accurate.

Methodology

The authors used a segmented regression approach to analyze taxable retail sales data before and after the smoking ban.

Limitations

The authors note potential discrepancies in data due to different inflation adjustments used by Ma and McClintock.

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication