Errors in Fracture Diagnoses in the Emergency Department
Author Information
Author(s): Peter Hallas, Trond Ellingsen
Primary Institution: Hålogalandssykehuset Harstad
Hypothesis
Are there common characteristics among patients who experience diagnostic errors in fracture diagnosis and is there a diurnal pattern in these errors?
Conclusion
A significant number of fractures were misdiagnosed during initial visits to the emergency department, particularly between 8 pm and 2 am.
Supporting Evidence
- 1% of all visits to the ED resulted in an error in fracture diagnosis.
- 3.1% of all fractures were not diagnosed at the initial visit to the ED.
- 86% of misdiagnosed cases had consequences for treatment.
- Errors peaked between 8 pm and 2 am, with 47% of errors occurring during this time.
Takeaway
Sometimes doctors make mistakes when checking for broken bones, especially at night when more people come in with injuries.
Methodology
Retrospective analysis of cases with missed fractures or misdiagnosed injuries over two years, comparing with a control group of correctly diagnosed fractures.
Potential Biases
Some doctors may not document language difficulties or advice from senior colleagues, which could introduce bias.
Limitations
The study may underestimate errors due to retrospective data collection and potential loss to follow-up.
Participant Demographics
The study involved patients visiting the ED for injuries, with no significant demographic risk factors identified for misdiagnosis.
Statistical Information
P-Value
<0.005
Statistical Significance
p<0.005
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website