Evaluating the Reproducibility and Verifiability of Nutrition Research: A Case Study of Studies Assessing the Relationship Between Potatoes and Colorectal Cancer
2024

Evaluating Nutrition Research on Potatoes and Colorectal Cancer

Sample size: 18 publication Evidence: low

Author Information

Author(s): Jamshidi-Naeini Yasaman, Vorland Colby J., Kapoor Pranav, Ortyl Bailey, Mineo Jocelyn, Still Luke, Sorsor Korlu, Rodney Shelby, Tooze Xander, Flickinger Brent, Henschel Beate, Dickinson Stephanie L., Allison David B.

Primary Institution: Indiana University School of Public Health-Bloomington, IN, USA

Hypothesis

How reproducible and verifiable are studies assessing the relationship between potato consumption and colorectal cancer?

Conclusion

Research on the relationship between potato consumption and colorectal cancer risk is insufficiently reproducible and verifiable.

Supporting Evidence

  • Eighteen studies were included, none of which publicly share data.
  • We managed to access data for only two studies, successfully reproducing and verifying the results for one.
  • The majority of studies exhibited a high risk of bias, with significant limitations in reporting quality and methodological rigor.

Takeaway

The study looked at how trustworthy research is about potatoes and cancer. They found that most studies didn't share their data, making it hard to check their results.

Methodology

The study updated systematic reviews and assessed the design, execution, and reporting quality of studies on potatoes and colorectal cancer, attempting to reproduce and verify results by requesting raw data from authors.

Potential Biases

The majority of studies exhibited a high risk of bias, primarily due to measurement weaknesses and lack of proper data handling.

Limitations

The study did not preregister its search or analytic plans, and only focused on potato-CRC associations, which may overlook errors in other aspects.

Participant Demographics

Studies included both men and women, with some focusing exclusively on women, across 12 different countries.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1101/2024.12.01.24318272

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication