Percent body fat estimations in college women using field and laboratory methods: a three-compartment model approach
2007

Estimating Body Fat in College Women: Comparing Methods

Sample size: 30 publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Moon Jordan R, Hull Holly R, Tobkin Sarah E, Teramoto Masaru, Karabulut Murat, Roberts Michael D, Ryan Eric D, Kim So Jung, Dalbo Vincent J, Walter Ashley A, Smith Abbie T, Cramer Joel T, Stout Jeffrey R

Primary Institution: Department of Health and Exercise Science, University of Oklahoma, Norman, USA

Hypothesis

This investigation sought to determine the validity of field and laboratory methods for estimating percent fat in healthy college-age women compared to the Siri three-compartment model.

Conclusion

Data suggest that the BP and HW are valid laboratory methods when compared to the 3C model to estimate %fat in college-age Caucasian women.

Supporting Evidence

  • All methods produced acceptable total error values compared to the 3C model.
  • Both laboratory methods produced similar total error values when compared to the 3C model.
  • The field methods produced acceptable total error values ranging from 1.8 – 3.8 %fat.
  • BIA-AK yielded the lowest total error among the field methods.
  • The study validated the use of BP and HW for estimating %fat in college-age women.
  • NIR, BIA-AK, BIA-Lohman, SF3JPW, and SF3WB are valid alternatives when laboratory methods are unavailable.
  • Significant constant errors were detected for HW and SF3JPW.

Takeaway

The study looked at different ways to measure body fat in college women and found that both lab methods and some field methods work well.

Methodology

Thirty Caucasian women had their %fat estimated using various methods including BIA, NIR, skinfold equations, hydrostatic weighing, and air-displacement plethysmography.

Potential Biases

Caution should be used when relying on any one method to identify %fat in small groups or individuals due to individual variations.

Limitations

The estimates of %fat from the 3C model may have greater agreement with methods that include HW, and the use of a criterion method for TBW could influence results.

Participant Demographics

Thirty Caucasian women aged 21.1 ± 1.5 years.

Statistical Information

P-Value

p ≤ 0.006

Statistical Significance

p ≤ 0.006

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1186/1550-2783-4-16

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication