Evaluating Instructor Feedback Practices in Clinical Learning
Author Information
Author(s): Tumwine Moreen, Mucunguzi Boaz, Walker Guti, Munabi Ian, Mubuuke Aloysious, Kiguli Sarah
Primary Institution: Kampala International University
Hypothesis
How do clinical tutors provide feedback to medical students in a developing country?
Conclusion
Clinical tutors provided constructive feedback but lacked direct observation and student reflection, leading to student dissatisfaction.
Supporting Evidence
- Most tutors provided constructive and timely feedback.
- Students expressed dissatisfaction with the feedback due to its absence and harshness.
- Immediate feedback was appreciated, but some feedback was delayed and inconsistent.
- Challenges included students not being receptive to feedback and individual differences in learning styles.
- Feedback practices lacked direct observation of student performance.
Takeaway
Teachers give feedback to students to help them learn, but sometimes students feel the feedback isn't helpful or is too harsh.
Methodology
Qualitative study with in-depth interviews of 14 tutors and 22 students.
Potential Biases
Potential bias in self-reported feedback practices from tutors.
Limitations
Data collected from one institution may limit generalizability; reliance on reported speech may not reflect actual practices.
Participant Demographics
14 tutors (8 males, 6 females) and 22 students (12 males, 10 females) with a median age of 23.
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)
Want to read the original?
Access the complete publication on the publisher's website