General aptitude and the assumption of truth in deductively rational reasoning about probable but false antecedent to consequent relations
2009

General Aptitude and Truth in Deductive Reasoning

Sample size: 362 publication Evidence: high

Author Information

Author(s): Walter Schroyens, Lieve Fleerackers, Sunile Maes

Primary Institution: University of Leuven

Hypothesis

Do people with higher general aptitude adhere more to the truth-assumption in deductive reasoning?

Conclusion

The study found that individuals with higher general aptitude are more likely to inhibit conflicting background knowledge when reasoning, supporting the truth-assumption.

Supporting Evidence

  • Participants with higher general aptitude showed smaller counter-example effects on valid arguments.
  • The truth-assumption was found to be a necessary component of deductively rational behavior.
  • General ability was positively related to the size of the logical validity effect.

Takeaway

The study shows that smarter people are better at ignoring information that contradicts what they initially believe to be true when solving problems.

Methodology

Two experiments were conducted with high school students evaluating conditional inference problems with varying counter-examples.

Potential Biases

Potential biases may arise from the educational background of participants, as they were all students preparing for higher education.

Limitations

The study's sample was limited to Flemish high school students, which may not represent broader populations.

Participant Demographics

Participants were 11th- and 12th-grade students from Flemish high schools, with varying levels of general aptitude.

Statistical Information

P-Value

p<0.00001

Statistical Significance

p<0.00001

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.2478/v10053-008-0079-z

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication