Representation and Re-Presentation in Litigation Science
2008

Understanding the Role of Science in Legal Proceedings

publication Evidence: moderate

Author Information

Author(s): Sheila Jasanoff

Primary Institution: Harvard University

Hypothesis

Judicial screening of scientific evidence is flawed and does not account for the dynamics of litigation.

Conclusion

The article argues that courts should recognize the complexities of scientific representation in litigation to avoid relying on unreliable evidence.

Supporting Evidence

  • Judicial screening fails to consider the dynamics of litigation.
  • Courts often rely on flawed criteria to assess scientific evidence.
  • Scientific knowledge is often constructed in response to legal disputes.

Takeaway

This study explains that how science is shown in court can change what people think about it, and judges need to be careful about how they decide what science is good or bad.

Potential Biases

Judicial biases may influence the interpretation of scientific evidence.

Limitations

The article does not provide empirical data or specific case studies to support its claims.

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

10.1289/ehp.9976

Want to read the original?

Access the complete publication on the publisher's website

View Original Publication